The Spongetones - 2006 - Mersey Christmas

Jamie Hoover (guitars, vocals, occasional bass and drums)
Steve Stoeckel (bass, vocals, guitars)
Rob Thorne (drums, percussion)
Pat Walters (guitars, vocals and keyboards)

Wikipedia

1 It Came Upon A Midnight Clear
2 Steve Greeting
3 Christmas Boy
4 Christmasland
5 Santa Claus Is Coming To Town/Jamie Greeting
6 Dance Of The Sugar Plum Fairy
7 Carol Of The Guitars
8 Blue Christmas
9 Pat Greeting
10 God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen
11 Christmas Song
12 Merry After-Christmas
13 Little Wiped-out Drummer Boy
14 Rob Greeting
15 Jingle Bells
16 Santa Goes To Mayberry
17 We'll Have The Brightest Christmas
18 There's a Star