Jellyfish - 1993 - Spilt Milk

Andy Sturmer: Vocals, Drums, Some Guitar, Keyboards
Roger Joseph Manning, Jr.: Keyboards, Piano, Vocals
Tim Smith: Bass, Vocals

Wikipedia

1. Hush
2. Joining a Fan Club
3. Sebrina, Paste, and Plato
4. New Mistake
5. Glutton of Sympathy
6. The Ghost at Number One
7. Bye, Bye, Bye
8. All Is Forgiven
9. Russian Hill
10. He's My Best Friend
11. Too Much, Too Little, Too Late
12. Brighter Day