Jellyfish - 1990 - Bellybutton

Andy Sturmer: Vocals, Drums, Some Guitar & Keyboards.
Roger Joseph Manning Jr. - Keyboards, Piano, Harpsichord & Vocals.
Jason Falkner: Guitars, Bass & Background Vocals.
Chris Manning: Band Witchdoctor & Mime.

Wikipedia

1. The Man I Used To Be
2. That Is Why
3. The King Is Half-Undressed
4. I Wanna Stay Home
5. She Still Loves Him
6. All I Want Is Everything
7. Now She Knows She's Wrong
8. Bedspring Kiss
9. Baby's Coming Back
10. Calling Sarah